How to choose xylitol-free peanut butter for dogs
The safest jar is the one whose current label you’ve just read. Here is exactly what we look for, in the order we look for it.
Step 1: Rule out xylitol
Xylitol is a sugar substitute that is toxic to dogs (FDA). Scan the ingredient list for:
- xylitol
- birch sugar (or birch bark sugar)
- E967
If you see any of these, put it back. If the label is unclear, contact the maker or choose another jar.
Step 2: Be extra careful with these products
- “Sugar-free,” “no sugar added,” “keto,” “low carb” spreads
- Protein, “powdered” or flavored peanut butters
- Peanut butter cups, cookies and snacks — those also often contain chocolate
Step 3: Prefer a short, plain list
For treats we prefer jars where the ingredients are peanuts, or peanuts and salt. Unsalted is the better choice. Many “natural” jars separate in the jar — stir well before you measure.
Step 4: Re-check over time
Brands reformulate. Check the label each time you buy a new jar, even of a brand you already use.
Examples to check in US stores
These are common US products whose standard versions have often been sold with a short ingredient list. We are not guaranteeing them — read the current label on the exact jar you buy:
- Skippy Natural (check: not a reduced-sugar or flavored variety)
- Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter
- Smucker’s Natural Peanut Butter
- Your grocery store’s own “natural” or “just peanuts” peanut butter
Search: xylitol-free peanut butter on Amazon · unsalted natural peanut butter on Amazon
Amazon links on this page are plain search links. Affiliate tags can be added later; if they are, we’ll disclose it here.
How much to use
At about 6 kcal per gram, peanut butter fills a small dog’s treat budget fast. See peanut butter in the fridge guide and run the numbers in the calculator.
Work out your dog’s treat budget